How to make fair random teams (and balance them by skill)
The team generator in step 1 is our own free tool.
Picking teams is one of those jobs that goes wrong in front of everyone. Captains choosing in turn leaves the same people standing at the end, friends end up together, and one team gets all the strong players. Here’s how to split any group fairly, whether it’s a PE class, a five-a-side game, a workshop or a set of breakout rooms.
Quick answer
| Situation | Best option |
|---|---|
| Any group, names on a list | 1. Our Random Team Generator |
| Mixed abilities, close games wanted | 2. Balanced teams with a snake draft |
| Everyone in one room, no screen | 3. Counting off or playing cards |
| Online meeting | 4. Breakout rooms |
1. A random team generator (our tool): quickest option
The fastest way is our own Random Team Generator. Paste a list, choose how to split it, and the teams appear in one click.
- Open usefultools.fyi/team-generator.
- Paste the names into Names, one per line. You can copy a column straight from a class list or spreadsheet.
- Under Split by, choose Number of teams or People per team, and type the number.
- Press Make teams. Each team appears as a card.
- Press Shuffle again for a new split with the same settings.
To share the result, Copy as text gives a plain list for a chat, email or document. Presentation shows only the teams in large text on the whole screen, which is ideal for a projector or a shared screen.
You can click a team name on a card and type a new one, such as “Red”, “Table 3” or “Room B”. The names are kept for the next shuffle. Your list and settings stay in your browser on that device, and nothing is uploaded.
Why it’s fair: the list is shuffled with your browser’s cryptographic random number generator (crypto.getRandomValues) using a Fisher–Yates shuffle, so every order of the names is equally likely. The order in which teams receive people is shuffled too, so Team 1 doesn’t always get the extra person when the numbers are uneven.
Number of teams or people per team?
Choose by what you know in advance:
- Number of teams when you have a fixed number of pitches, tables or rooms. With 14 people in 4 teams you get two teams of 4 and two teams of 3.
- People per team when the activity needs a certain size, like five-a-side or groups of three for a discussion. No team is ever larger than the number you choose: 22 people with 5 per team gives two teams of 5 and three of 4.
Either way, team sizes never differ by more than one, and the line above the cards tells you the exact split.
2. Balanced teams: random, but not lopsided
A plain shuffle gives everyone the same chance of landing in any team. But by bad luck, the three strongest players can still end up together. For sport, quizzes or gaming, that makes for a dull game.
The fix is a snake draft. Sort people from strongest to weakest, then hand them out in order 1, 2, 3, then backwards 3, 2, 1, then forwards again. The team that picked last in one round picks first in the next, which evens out the totals.
In our tool:
- Tick Balance by skill level.
- Add a level after each name, like
Anna, 3orAnna (3). Higher means stronger. - Press Make teams.
People with the same level are still shuffled against each other, and the order of the teams in the first round is random, so the result is balanced without being predictable. Each card shows the team’s total, and the line above the cards shows the gap between the highest and lowest team.
Tips for skill levels:
- Rough levels work better than precise scores. A 1–3 or 1–5 scale is plenty.
- Anyone without a level counts as 0, and the tool warns you about them.
- In balanced mode the cards show each person’s level. If you’d rather the class didn’t see them, make the teams before you switch on the projector.
3. Without a screen: counting off and playing cards
When you’re on a field with no laptop, two old methods still work:
- Counting off. Go round the group saying “1, 2, 3, 4, 1, 2…”, and everyone with the same number forms a team. It’s quick, but friends quickly learn to stand apart or together to land in the right team.
- Playing cards or coloured bibs. Shuffle a set with one card per person, using one suit or colour per team, and hand them out face down. This is fairer than counting off, as long as nobody sees the cards before they’re dealt.
Neither method can balance by skill, and both take longer with a big group.
4. Breakout rooms in online meetings
Zoom and Teams can both assign people to breakout rooms automatically, which is fine for a quick discussion. A team generator helps when you want more control:
- Make the groups before the meeting, with People per team set to the size you want.
- Rename each team after its room, then use Copy as text and paste the list into the chat, so people know where they’re going.
- Use Balance by skill level to spread experienced people across rooms, for example one facilitator or one senior colleague per group.
Tips for classrooms and sports
- Show the teams all at once. Put them on the projector with Presentation so nobody is picked last in front of the class.
- Don’t reshuffle on request. Decide before you press Make teams whether the first result stands. Pressing Shuffle again until certain friends are together undoes the fairness.
- Keep score fairly too. Our Click Counter keeps several named counters at once, one per team.
- Choose who starts. Once the teams are made, put the team names on our Wheel Spinner to decide who goes first or who picks ends.